Judge In Kirk Assassination Case Makes First Big Ruling

Fourth District Court Judge Tony Graf has approved a motion allowing Tyler Robinson to wear civilian clothing during court appearances as his trial progresses. Robinson is accused of assassinating conservative activist Charlie Kirk last month.

The judge ruled that Robinson should appear “as one who is presumed innocent” for pretrial hearings but denied his request to appear without restraints due to security concerns. Media are also barred from photographing or filming Robinson’s restraints or his courtroom entries and exits.

Kirk, 31, co-founder of Turning Point USA, was fatally shot on September 10 at Utah Valley University during a debate. A prominent conservative figure, he was closely aligned with former President Donald Trump. Robinson faces multiple charges, including aggravated murder, with prosecutors seeking the death penalty.

Robinson participated in the hearing remotely, confirming he could hear proceedings. Defense attorneys argued that showing him in jail attire could bias jurors, while prosecutors emphasized security and identification needs. Graf decided that Robinson’s presumption of innocence outweighs the minor inconvenience of wearing civilian clothes.

The judge noted Robinson has no prior criminal record and has behaved appropriately in custody. However, he stressed the seriousness of the charges and the high risk of publicity affecting potential jurors, highlighting the case’s emotional and public nature.

Both sides require additional time for the discovery process and motions, including whether future non-evidentiary hearings should remain remote and camera access should be restricted. FBI Director Kash Patel confirmed the bureau is continuing to follow leads in the case.

Robinson’s next court date is January 16. Defense attorney Skye Lazaro noted that both prosecution and defense have limited information so far, and the discovery process could take up to a year before a preliminary hearing.