Eugenea Collins Claims She Is Madeleine McCann and Cites a DNA Test. Here’s What That Test Actually Shows

In this story
Eugenea Collins, a 22-year-old from Arkansas, has claimed she is Madeleine McCann, the British girl who disappeared in 2007 during a family vacation in Praia da Luz, Portugal.
She has presented an ancestry DNA result as support. That test does not show a genetic link to the McCann family, and police have not treated her claim as credible. This is her claim, not a confirmed identification.
What Eugenea Collins Says About Her DNA Test
Collins has said she began to wonder about her identity after watching Julia Wandelt, a Polish woman who also claimed to be Madeleine, appear on the U.S. talk show “Dr. Phil.”
“If it wasn’t for me seeing her (Wandelt) on the Dr. Phil show, I would’ve never known,” she told DailyMail.com, in remarks later reported by Metro and Global News. “In a way, her stupidity actually helped me find my family.” She has also said age-progression images of Madeleine felt, to her, like looking in a mirror.
Collins says her birthday is October 23, 2002, which would make her close in age to Madeleine, whose birthday is May 12, 2003. She has also described trouble getting a consistent ID and a copy of her birth certificate.
An ancestry test, she says, shows she is 68 percent English and Northwestern European. She argues that result supports her claim. At the same time, she has acknowledged that the test shows no direct DNA connection to the McCann family.
A DNA expert, Professor Turi King, later told Metro that ancestry tests are not a forensic identification. “Ancestry DNA is not specific enough to be able to say that Julia or Eugenia is Madeleine McCann, not by a long stretch,” she said. European ancestry is also common in the United States and would not, on its own, prove a link to one missing child.
Why Police Have Not Accepted Eugenea Collins’s Claim
Collins has said Arkansas police have not taken her seriously, and that she has tried to contact Operation Grange, the Metropolitan Police investigation into Madeleine’s disappearance. As of the February 2025 reporting, there was no public sign that investigators had verified her story.
Social media users also pointed to a distinctive eye defect Madeleine had, which they said they did not see in Collins’s photos. Collins has offered other explanations for mismatches, including scars on her ears. Those comments do not amount to evidence.
She has also said the man her family identified as her father, Eugene Collins, resembles Christian Brueckner, a German man who became a suspect in Madeleine’s disappearance and who later received convictions for other serious sexual offenses. Brueckner has denied involvement in the McCann case. A resemblance claim is not proof of a connection.
Wandelt’s earlier claim is a useful contrast. A DNA test in her case showed she was of Polish heritage, and a private investigator publicly said the results did not support the Madeleine story. Polish police also disputed her claim. No comparable forensic test has shown that Collins is Madeleine, and no report has described a test that formally ties her to the McCann family.
Madeleine’s parents have already lived for years with false leads and public claims. Nothing in Collins’s account changes the official fact that Madeleine remains missing, and that this latest claim remains unproven.
For Metro’s report on the claim and the limits of ancestry DNA, see Metro’s coverage.
Related: He Went Home From School With a Sore Throat at 12 — and Lost the Next Decade of His Life


